saplin

Methodology

How we score funds

The saplin Score rates a mutual fund from 0 to 10 against the funds most like it. We rate a fund on a few separate qualities first, its pillars, and then combine them with weights that depend on what kind of fund it is.

What the Score is

A score of 9.0 in Small Cap means the fund is one of the strongest small-cap funds we track. It says nothing about whether small caps suit you. Scores are only comparable within a peer group: an 8.0 liquid fund and an 8.0 small-cap fund are not "equally good".

A typical fund scores about 7. A fund has to stand out, not just rank well, to reach 8 or more. A fund that trails its benchmark or costs clearly more than its peers falls below 6. 8.0 and above is Strong, below 6.0 is Weak, and anything in between is Neutral.

The pillars

Each pillar is a weighted average of a few measures. The weight of each measure inside its pillar is shown next to it.

Loading…

How the pillars are weighted

What matters depends on the kind of fund. An index fund's returns are set by its index, so cost and how closely it tracks the index decide which one is better. For an active fund, the manager's results and the fund's behaviour matter more.

Loading…

Fund-of-funds, retirement, children's and life-cycle schemes use the Active equity, Hybrid or Debt weights depending on what they mainly hold, read from their official benchmark.

How a measure becomes a score

Every measure is scored from 0 to 10, and a typical result scores 7. How we decide what counts as good depends on the measure:

Loading…

A measure is only scored when at least 5 funds in the group have it.

Peer groups

Funds are compared within their SEBI category, with these exceptions where a category mixes very different funds:

Only funds with at least a year of history count towards a group's size. If fewer than 5 share an index or a benchmark, we use the whole category instead.

Newer funds

We rate funds on their last 3 years. A fund with 1 to 3 years of history is rated on its last year, against every peer's last year, and its Score is then reduced because a short record is less reliable. It is multiplied by 0.85 at one year, rising steadily to no reduction at three years. Funds younger than a year are Not rated.

Missing data and Not rated

When we can't measure something for a fund, its weight is shared among the measures and pillars we can. For example, a fund with no official benchmark has its alpha and capture ratios measured against the median fund of its category instead. A fund is Not rated when:

Direct and Regular plans

Both plans of a scheme hold the same portfolio, so the Regular plan shows the same Score as its Direct plan. The Regular plan's higher expense ratio is shown on its own.

How SIFs are scored

Specialized Investment Funds (SIFs) are a newer kind of fund, with a ₹10 lakh minimum, that may take short positions. They are all under two years old, so they are scored by their own rules, not the mutual-fund ones, but shown on the same scale: 0 to 10, one decimal, Strong from 8.0, Weak below 6.0. A SIF needs three months of NAVs to be rated (a short record makes the capture ratios noisy, so treat early scores with care), and its score stays provisional until it has three years of history.

Four pillars, weighted Returns 10%, Risk 60%, Cost and tax 20%, Manager 10%. A pillar we cannot measure hands its weight to the others.

Fund-size levels are our own estimates, set for how much each strategy can trade and how few stocks can be shorted. Comfortable up to ₹8,000 crore for hybrid long-short, ₹6,000 crore for active asset allocator, ₹3,000 crore for equity long-short, ₹2,000 crore for sector rotation and ₹1,500 crore for equity ex-top-100; stretched up to twice that, strained beyond. Under ₹250 crore counts as small, under ₹50 crore as very small.

Benchmarks are rebuilt from NSE’s published daily index closes (Nifty 500 TRI, Nifty 200 TRI, and a daily-rebalanced 50:50 blend of Nifty 50 TRI and the Nifty Composite G-Sec index for the Nifty 50 Hybrid Composite Debt 50:50). BSE 500 TRI is estimated from BSE’s price index plus the Nifty 500’s dividend yield. CRISIL owns its indices and publishes no daily file, so for CRISIL Hybrid 50+50 and 85+15 and for one gold-and-silver blend we draw a labelled stand-in from NSE index and gold/silver fund NAV data; it feeds capture, beta, the chart and the Returns pillar, always labelled as a stand-in. A SIF whose benchmark we cannot rebuild at all (those containing the iCOMDEX commodity index), or that lists none, is measured against the Nifty 50 TRI instead, labelled as a stand-in: it feeds capture, beta, drawdowns, the chart and the Returns pillar. Capture and beta use daily returns.

What the Score does not do

When it updates

Once a month. Every measure runs up to the last day of the previous month, so the Score doesn't move day to day with NAVs. The fund page shows the month the Score is as of.

Definitions

Windows are the last 36 months for funds with 3+ years of history, and the last 12 months for newer funds. Returns are month-end to month-end unless noted. The risk-free rate is 7% a year.

Average rolling 1-year return
The 1-year return ending at each month-end inside the window, averaged. For newer funds, their 1-year return.
Alpha
Return above what the fund's market exposure explains: the annualised intercept of its monthly returns over the risk-free rate, regressed on its benchmark's. If the fund has no official benchmark, the category's median fund stands in for it.
Upside and downside capture
The fund's total return in the months its benchmark rose (fell), as a percentage of the benchmark's. Lower downside capture is better.
Deepest fall
The largest fall from a peak inside the window, on daily NAVs.
Sortino ratio
Annual return above the risk-free rate, divided by the volatility of monthly returns below it.
Standard deviation
Volatility of monthly returns, annualised. Lower is better.
Fund size
AMFI's latest average assets, all plans together, scored against fixed levels in ₹ crore that are the same for every fund of a category (table below). Under ₹50 crore is too small and scores 0; ₹50 to ₹250 crore is small and scores 5. Small funds cost more to run (their expense ratios are higher) and can be merged or closed. From ₹250 crore a fund scores 10, until it passes its category's comfortable level (5, stretched) and then its strained level (0). Only some categories have an upper level, because only some hold shares that are hard to trade in size. A fund above its comfortable level also has its final Score reduced: by up to 5% at the strained level, rising in a straight line to 30% once the fund is twice that size. The small and mid cap levels come from AMFI's liquidity stress test (days needed to sell half the portfolio) and are rounded; the others are our estimates scaled from those. They are our working levels, not an industry standard.
Months beating the category median
The share of months in the window when the fund's return beat the median fund of its peer group.
Worst 1-year return
The lowest of the rolling 1-year returns inside the 3-year window. Not used for newer funds.
Information ratio vs the category median
The fund's average monthly lead over the median fund, divided by how much that lead varies, annualised. High means it stayed ahead steadily.
Expense ratio
The current Direct-plan TER. Change over a year: the median TER during the score month minus the same month a year earlier. A cut scores higher.
Longest manager tenure
How long the longest-serving current manager has run the fund, from AMFI's manager start dates. Credit stops growing at 7 years: past a full market cycle, 15 years isn't twice as reassuring as 7.
Record at their other funds
For the other active funds the current managers run today at the same fund house, each fund's information ratio since they took charge: its annual return above its benchmark (or its category median), divided by how much it strayed from it. This makes a debt fund half a point ahead count like an equity fund three points ahead. Funds count from a year in charge, each fund's ratio is capped at ±1.5, and funds are weighted by years in charge up to 5. Index and cash-like funds (liquid, arbitrage and similar) are left out, since they say little about skill. AMFI doesn't publish funds a manager ran in the past, so those aren't counted.
Manager change
When the longest-serving manager leaves, the Manager pillar loses 5 points for 12 months, fading to nothing by 24 months. We detect departures by comparing AMFI's manager lists month to month; we started recording in September 2026.
Tracking error
For index funds: how much the fund's monthly return differs from its index's total return, annualised. Lower is better. Gold and silver funds all track India's domestic spot price of the metal, which has no free price history (the international price in rupees differs from it by several percent a month because of the Indian premium or discount). So they are measured against the median fund of the same metal: straying from the pack means straying from the metal.
Slippage beyond the expense ratio
The fund's annual return minus its index's, plus its expense ratio. This is what the fund lost to the index beyond its fees, from cash held, trading costs and timing. Higher is better. For gold and silver funds: the annual return against the median fund of the same metal, plus the fund's expense-ratio gap to that median fund.

Loading…

Where the data comes from

AMFI (NAVs, expense ratios, fund size, managers and official benchmarks), NSE index archives for total-return indices (reconstructed from price indices and dividend yields where NSE publishes no daily total return), and our own calculations. Category medians use current schemes only, so they carry survivorship bias like every screener.