saplin

Specialized Investment Funds

SIF vs mutual fund vs PMS: what actually differs

Three ways to hand money to a professional manager in India, differing in how much you need, what the manager may do and how you are taxed. Here they are side by side, with live numbers for the 39 SIFs on saplin.

The three side by side

Mutual fundSIFPMS
Minimum to startA few hundred to a few thousand rupees, depending on the fund₹10 lakh per investor (PAN), counted across all the SIFs of one fund house₹50 lakh
What you ownUnits of a pooled fundUnits of a pooled fundShares and bonds held in a demat account in your name, run for you
Short positionsNo. Derivatives are used mainly to hedgeYes, through derivatives, within limits (unhedged short exposure is capped at 25% of net assets)Depends on the portfolio manager's strategy
Daily NAV and redemptionYes, for open-ended fundsNAV is published daily; some SIFs redeem only in set windows (interval funds)No NAV. You see the value of your own portfolio
How costs show upExpense ratio inside the NAVExpense ratio inside the NAVManagement fee, often with a performance fee, agreed with the manager
How gains are taxedOn redemption, by how much of the fund is in sharesOn redemption, by how much of the fund is in sharesOn each sale in your own account, as your own gains

Is a SIF a mutual fund?

It is run by a mutual fund house and is bought and sold like one, but it is a separate SEBI category with its own rules: a ₹10 lakh minimum per investor and the freedom to take short positions through derivatives. It sits between a mutual fund and a PMS.

Why would a SIF cost more than an ordinary mutual fund?

On saplin, the Direct-plan expense ratios of the 39 SIFs we have a figure for run from 0.34% to 4.54% a year, with a median of 1.63%. A long-short fund trades derivatives and holds cash against its margin, and a young fund spreads its running costs over a small asset base, so its expense ratio can be high and move with its size. Compare the Direct-plan figure on each fund's page.

What does a SIF give up compared with a mutual fund?

Reach and, often, history. The ₹10 lakh minimum keeps most small investors out, most SIFs launched in 2025 or 2026, and some can be redeemed only in set windows. Their returns and risk numbers rest on far less data than an old mutual fund's.

What does a SIF give up compared with a PMS?

Control. In a PMS the securities sit in your own account and the manager can tailor the portfolio; a SIF is one pooled portfolio for every investor. In return the SIF has a lower minimum, a published daily NAV and a fund-level tax treatment.

Which one is better?

None is better in general. They suit different amounts, risks and tax positions, and saplin does not know yours. What can be compared is evidence: each SIF's returns against its benchmark, how much of the falls it took, its cost and its manager. That is what the saplin SIF score summarises.

Keep reading

This page explains the product. It is not investment, tax or legal advice, and it does not know your goals, income or tax position. See the disclaimer.